data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0bb64/0bb645a0b9896387c5d3448d30ce8b91176ddbda" alt=""
First I'll review Arrival and begin by saying I don't like science fiction movies, especially those that take themselves seriously. Unfortunately, Arrival was no exception.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b6626/b6626e71041d63baab45e0a152242949bd89119c" alt=""
I definitely can't recommend seeing Arrival. And I certainly don't understand why it was nominated.
Manchester by the Sea was more entertaining than Arrival, but far from enjoyable. It's a sad film about a family's hardships and how the individuals handle them. The acting is good and I liked seeing Casey Affleck in a lead role. But the overall film is ruined by it's pace, which is painfully slow, and abrupt ending.
Nevertheless, Manchester by the Sea is worth seeing. It's just not Academy Award nominee worthy in my mind.
**********************
So this year I managed to see seven of the nine movie nominees before the Awards Ceremony. Out of those seven, I still pick Hacksaw Ridge for the win. Good luck, Mel Gibson!